Charlie Day as Charlie Kelly

Glenn Howerton as Dennis Reynolds

Rob McElhenney as Ronald "Mac" McDonald

Kaitlin Olson as Deandra "Sweet Dee" Reynolds

Danny DeVito as Frank Reynolds

David Huddleston as Eugene Hamilton

Gregory Scott Cummins as Luther McDonald

Sandy Martin as Mrs. McDonald

Lynne Marie Stewart as Bonnie Kelly

Pablo Schreiber as Ricky Falcone

Ryan Michelle Bathe as Woman Office Worker

Mike Beaver as Man Office Worker

Derek Waters as Toy Store Clerk

Mark Povinelli as Tiny

Preston Bailey as Young Mac

Charlie Carter as Young Dennis

Harley Graham as Young Dee

Robbie Tucker as Young Charlie

Timothy E. Goodwin as Christmas Dad

Donovan Scott as Santa Claus in Mall

Karly Rothenberg as Another Mom

Marc Anthony Samuel as Raisin #1 (voice)

Gary Anthony Williams as Snowman (voice) / Raisin #2 (voice)

Michael Yurchak as Christmas Elf (voice)

Christopher Lloyd as Santa Claus John #2 (uncredited)