Hugh Grant as Mr. Reed

Sophie Thatcher as Sister Barnes

Chloe East as Sister Paxton

Topher Grace as Elder Kennedy

Elle Young as Prophet

Julie Lynn-Mortensen as Pedestrian

Haylie Hansen as Teenager

Elle McKinnon as Teenager

Hanna Huffman as Teenager

Anesha Bailey as Neighbor

Miguel Castillo as Neighbor

Stephanie Lavigne as Believer

Wendy Gorling as Disciple

River Codack as Missionary #1 (uncredited)

Carolyn Adair as Driver with Car (uncredited)