Paul Newman as Sully Sullivan

Bruce Willis as Carl Roebuck

Melanie Griffith as Toby Roebuck

Jessica Tandy as Beryl Peoples

Dylan Walsh as Peter Sullivan

Pruitt Taylor Vince as Rub Squeers

Gene Saks as Wirf Wirfley

Josef Sommer as Clive Peoples Jr.

Philip Seymour Hoffman as Officer Raymer

Philip Bosco as Judge Flatt

Catherine Dent as Charlotte Sullivan

Alexander Goodwin as Will Sullivan

Carl J. Matusovich as Wacker Sullivan

Jay Patterson as Jocko

Jerry Mayer as Ollie Quinn

Angela Pietropinto as Cass

Alice Drummond as Hattie

Margo Martindale as Birdy

Angelica Page as Ruby

Richard Mawe as Ralph

Joe Paparone as Rufus

Shannah Laumeister Stern as Didi

John Leighton as Funeral Director

Kenneth Frawley as Horace Yaney

John Marcus Powell as Whit

Frank W. Inness as Garbage Man

Page Johnson as C. W. Lomax

William Raymond Calhoun as Vernon

Bob Heitman as Lawyer from Albany

Drenda Spohnholtz as Girl at the Country Club

Gerry Robert Byrne as Charlie

Anibal O. Lleras as Juror (uncredited)

Elizabeth Wilson as Vera (uncredited)