Melissa Joan Hart as Ella

Presley Allard as Mary Bailey

Olivia Scriven as Veronica

Connor McMahon as Willard Simms

Luca Thunberg as Sammy Bailey

Laura Adamo as Cordelia

JaNae Armogan as Police Woman

Isabella Astbury as Young Mary Bailey

Dana Fradkin as Jennifer

Patrick Ludlow as Background performer (Police)

Barbara Saxberg as Judge Bristol

Michael Gordin Shore as Angus

Pierre Simpson as Pastor McCall

Paulyne Wei as Celine

Celina Myers as Susan (uncredited)