Diane Foster as Jeanie Cooper

Kelly Grant as Carol

Allison Lobel as Mary Lou

Zuri Starks as Megan

D'Andre Noiré as Lance Cooper

Zach Kanner as Sam

Miles Cooper as Eugene

Gavin Lee as Jim

Jamie B. Cline as Jackalope

Adam Slemon as Mayor Lou

Caitlin Oden as Sally

Faye Viviana as Annie Sue

Jackson Guitterrez as Sheriff

Richard Rivera as Pastor

Ronnie Prouty as Phil

Liana Montemayor as Teenager

Reed Foster as Teenager

Reed Foster as Megan’s Dad

Venice Wong as Carol and Jim’s Kid

Alexander Wong as Carol and Jim’s Kid

Harrison Wong as Carol and Jim’s Kid

Mason Wong as Carol and Jim’s Kid

Nathan Pratt as Easter Bunny

Zach DuFault as Fiddler

Levi Austin Morris as Beatrice Bunny

Bam Hall as 1872 Walburg Mayor

Mark Vogel as Zeke

Kayla Robinson as Church Lady

Taryn Leggett as Church Lady

Brenna Larsen as Church Lady

Ariel Barber as Church Lady

Mandie Hittleman as Church Lady

Juno as Ducky

William Morabito as Beau

Dan Lesser as Walburgonian

Emily Carpenter as Walburgonian

Diana Lobel as Walburgonian

Rachel Verbeek as Walburgonian

Heather Shoemaker as Walburgonian

Jacob Hyman as Walburgonian

Anthony Mastrocola as Walburgonian

Emily Browning as Walburgonian

Justin Wotring as Walburgonian

Lena Pham as Walburgonian

Joel Coryell as Walburgonian

Yana Nunn as Egg Hunt Kids

Gregory Nunn Jr. as Egg Hunt Kids

Luke Wotring as Egg Hunt Kids

Emma Wotring as Egg Hunt Kids

Stevie Notes as Carrot Cake Band

Claire Cunningham as Carrot Cake Band

Latavius Mulzac as Carrot Cake Band