Donald Sutherland as Father Robert Koesler

Charles Durning as Father Ted Nabors

Belinda Bauer as Pat Lennon

Josef Sommer as Lieutenant Koznicki

James Murtaugh as Robert Javison

Leila Danette as Mrs. Washington

Addison Powell as Father Edward Killeen

Kathleen Tolan as Sister Ann Vania

Tom Mardirosian as Detective Fallon

Anita Barone as Irene Jimenez

John Danelle as Detective Harris

Anna Minot as Sister Mary Martyrs

Lupe Ontiveros as Sophie

Roger Angelini as Brainard

B. Constance Barry as Sister Grace

Doris Biscoe as Newscaster

Sandy Broad as Librarian

Keith Brooks as Altar Boy

Bethany Carpenter as Nancy Baldwin

Joseph Conrad as Schommer

Richard Cottrell as Officer Mills

Bruce Economou as Priest

Rex Everhart as Father Skiarski

Lilian Ferguson as Funeral Woman

Stefan Gierasch as Trupiano

Harold Hansen as Father Lord

Cordis Heard as Sister Magdala

Robert Heller as Kane

Jihmi Kennedy as Officer Knight

Don Lessnau as Passing Cop

María López as Mrs. Jimenez

Mark Margolis as Father Max

Robert C. Maxwell as Father Marek

Sheldon Miller as Coney Island Customer

Joel Nash as Listening Priest

Ed Oldani as Patrolman Wozniak

Burt Pearson as Father Lasko

Sam Pollack as Father Dailey

David Regal as Father O'Day

Jordan Rodriguez as Jimenez Baby

Ed Ruffalo as Sergeant Ross

Edward Seamon as Father Harold Steele

Janet M. Smith as Cathy Javison

Peter Van Norden as Father McNiff

Josephine Vassalo as Mrs. Gates

Jo Mullin White as Prioress

Dennis Wrosch as Sister Vania's Beau

Jeffrey R. Dolan as Driver

Georgine Hall as

Michael Mili as Guest at Party (uncredited)

Jack White as Altar Boy (uncredited)