Penn Badgley as Jeff Buckley

Imogen Poots as Allie

Norbert Leo Butz as Hal Wilner

Ben Rosenfield as Tim Buckley

Frank Wood as Gary Lucas

William Sadler as Lee Underwood

Isabelle McNally as Jane Goldstein

Jessica Stone as Janine Nichols

Kate Nash as Carol

Jadyn Douglas as Linda

Ilana Levine as Paula

Stephen Tyrone Williams as Carter