Jena Malone as Mary Cummings

Mandy Moore as Hilary Faye

Macaulay Culkin as Roland

Patrick Fugit as Patrick

Eva Amurri as Cassandra

Heather Matarazzo as Tia

Martin Donovan as Pastor Skip

Mary-Louise Parker as Lillian

Chad Faust as Dean

Elizabeth Thai as Veronica

Valerie Bertinelli as Self

Birkett Turton as Mitch

Julia Arkos as PE Coach

Donna White as Trudy Mason

James Caldwell as Hairdresser

Nicki Clyne as Guitar Player

Aaron Douglas as Paramedic

Patricia Drake as Dean's Mother

Brent Fidler as Church Man

Jay Hilliker as Waiter / Host

John Innes as Pastor

Greg Kean as Dean's Father

Joe MacLeod as Lead Singer

Althea McAdam as Church Wife

Thomas Plustwik as Carpenter / Jesus

Syndie Skeeles as 3 Year Old Mary

Susan Wilkey as Pink Bouffant Lady