James Van Der Beek as Lincoln Rogers Dunnison

Rachael Leigh Cook as Caroline Dukes

Ashton Kutcher as George Durham

Dylan McDermott as Leander McNelly

Usher as Randolph Douglas Scipio

Tom Skerritt as Richard Dukes

Randy Travis as Frank Bones

Leonor Varela as Perdita

Brian Martell as Jean-Pierre Marsele

Alfred Molina as John King Fisher

Billy Morton as Abajo

Kate Newby as Henrietta Dukes

Robert Patrick as Sgt. John Armstrong

Gordon Michaels as Mariachi Guard

Joe Renteria as General Cortinas

Jon Abrahams as Berry Smith

Bob Bancroft as Auctioneer

Stephen Bridgewater as Older Ranger

Jordan Brower as Jake Dunnison

Anthony Crivello as Ringmaster

Oded Fehr as Anton Marsale

Derek Flores as Leary

Breon Gorman as Mrs. Dunnison

Eric Johnson as Rollins

Matt Keeslar as Suh Suh Sam

Matthew Kennedy as Ranch Hand Steve

Marco Leonardi as Jesus Sandoval

Brad Loree as Outlaw #3

David Millbern as Marshall

William Prael as Cale Dukes

A. Alexandra Sanford as Fisher's Prostitute

Jim Shield as Baldbum

Joe Spano as Mr. Dunnison

Vincent Spano as Ed Simms

Jesse G. Thompson as Purdy Dukes

Gareth Williams as Vigilante Vic

James Coburn as Narrator (voice) (uncredited)