Brittany Underwood as Natalie Johnston

Eva Igo as Gwen Johnston

Aaron Goehle as Tony Chandler

Ainsley Burch as Wendy Novak

Nicole Weber as Sadie Chandler

Mike Bredon as Detective Chandler

Kiki Yellam as Tori Taylor

Julia Zook as Lauren McClain

Kate Dailey as Meredith Davis

Joy Ford as April Brandt

Ellie Martin as Martha McClain

Ebony Ramquist as Anita Taylor

Dawan Scott as Detective Mitchell

Amy Jo Schmidt as Book Club Member

Ethan Lisdahl as High school Student

Deven Bromme as Jeff Davis

David T Bacchus as CSI Photographer