Colin Farrell as Peter Lake

Jessica Brown Findlay as Beverly Penn

Russell Crowe as Pearly Soames

William Hurt as Isaac Penn

Jennifer Connelly as Virginia Gamely

Will Smith as Judge

Eva Marie Saint as Willa (Adult)

Graham Greene as Humpstone John

Matt Bomer as Young Man

Kevin Durand as Cesar Tan

Kevin Corrigan as Romeo Tan

Lucy Griffiths as Mrs. Lake

Finn Wittrock as Gabriel

Neka Zang as Ballroom Dancer

Michael Crane as Ellis Isle Doctor

Brian Hutchison as Ellis Isle Official

Alan Doyle as Dingy Worthington

Jon Patrick Walker as Optometrist

Maurice Jones as Cecil Mature

Mckayla Twiggs as Young Willa

Matthew R. Staley as Oyster Boy

Scott Grimes as Carriage Driver

Brenda Wehle as Governess

Tom Morrissey as Butler

Joshua Henry as Gravesman

Ripley Sobo as Abby

Maggie Geha as Girl in Bed

Caitlin Dulany as Librarian

Norm Lewis as Custodian

Harriett D. Foy as Receptionist

Rob Campbell as Gwathmi

Scott Dillin as Grand Central Short Tail

Luis Augusto Figueroa as Ballroom Dancer

April Grace as Dr. Elizabeth Lee

Michelle Simone Miller as Humpstone John's Wife

Aidan Zusin as Immigrant Boy at Ellis Island