Nicolas Cage as John Koestler

Rose Byrne as Diana Wayland

Chandler Canterbury as Caleb Koestler

Ben Mendelsohn as Phil Bergman

Nadia Townsend as Grace Koestler

Terry Camilleri as Cashier

Lara Robinson as Lucinda Embry / Abby Wayland

Adrienne Pickering as Allison

Danielle Carter as Miss Taylor (1959)

Alethea McGrath as Miss Taylor (2009)

David Lennie as Principal Clark (1959)

D.G. Maloney as The Stranger

Alan Hopgood as Rev. Koestler

Joshua Long as Younger Caleb

Tamara Donnellan as Lucinda's Mother

Travis Waite as Lucinda's Father

Liam Hemsworth as Spencer

Harli Ames as Man in Duffle Coat

Alyssa McClelland as Flight Attendant

Gareth Yuen as Donald

Lesley Anne Mitchell as Stacey

Raymond Thomas as Teacher

Angie Diaz as Reporter

Kate Mylius as Student (uncredited)

Sarah Lawrence as New York Model (uncredited)