Marianna Palka as The Woman

Jason Ritter as The Man

Eric Edelstein as Eric

Mark Webber as Derek

Martin Starr as Simon

Tom Arnold as Dad

Jesse Garcia as Jose

Katherine Waterston as Katherine

Elisabeth Waterston as Elisabeth

Charles Durning as Charlie

Seth Gabel as Kissing Man

Bryce Dallas Howard as Kissing Woman

Marge Morgan as Old Woman

Tyler Ritter as Young Handsome Man

Jeremy Glazer as Café Patron

Hadrian Belove as Cinefile Customer

Jennifer Dubin as Cinefile Customer

Luke Hawes as Cinefile Customer

Peter Kloman as Cinefile Customer

Gordon Mahlon as Cinefile Customer

Cora Olson as Cinefile Customer

Doug Roy as Cinefile Customer

Mitch Yapko as Cinefile Customer

Hunter Stiebel as Skate Clerk

Albert Atri as Ice Skater

Scott Crichton as Ice Skater

Curtis Harrison as Ice Skater

Marty Laquidara as Ice Skater

James LeNouail as Ice Skater

Mike McNeil as Ice Skater

Adam Mitchell as Ice Skater

Steve Poplawski as Ice Skater

Perry Smiley as Ice Skater

Tracy White as Ice Skater

Dana LaRue as Receptionist

Michael Cole as Pedestrian

Rye Shelton as Pedestrian

Amanda Barnett as Restaurant Patron

Jason Kennedy as Restaurant Patron

John Monsour as Restaurant Patron

Leslie Monsour as Restaurant Patron

Nancy Morgan as Waitress

Amberlee Colson as Elle (uncredited)

Josh Holt as Jared (uncredited)