Craig Robinson as Anti-Christ

Anna Kendrick as Lindsey Lewis

John Francis Daley as Ben House

Ken Jeong as God

Rob Corddry as Mr. House

Thomas Lennon as Mr. Murphy

Tyler Labine as Shorter Wraith

Ana Gasteyer as Mrs. Lewis

Paul Scheer as Security Wraith

Rob Huebel as Morgan

Mark Sweatman as Jesus

Calum Worthy as Clark Lewis

John Michael Higgins as Mr. Lewis