Paul Rudd as Joel

Amy Poehler as Molly

Bill Hader as Kyle

Ellie Kemper as Karen

Cobie Smulders as Tiffany

Noureen DeWulf as Melanie

Jason Mantzoukas as Bob

Michael Ian Black as Trevor

Michaela Watkins as Habermeyer

Randall Park as Martinson

Christopher Meloni as Roland

Teyonah Parris as Wanda

Ed Helms as Eggbert

David Wain as Keith

Jack McBrayer as Oliver

Kenan Thompson as Teddy

Ken Marino as Tommy

John Rue as Bartender

Max Greenfield as Jake

Melanie Lynskey as Brenda

Erinn Hayes as Valerie

Aidan Koehler as Barista

Zandy Hartig as Katherine

Zak Orth as Waiter With Pole

Norah Jones as Herself

Adam Scott as Sound Engineer

John Stamos as Assistant Engineer

Maureen Mueller as Pam

Michael Murphy as Roger

Alberto Vazquez as Mexican Waiter

Lynn Cohen as Bubby

Jeffrey Dean Morgan as Frank

Michael Shannon as Spike

Gameela Wright as Police Officer

Judith Sheindlin as Judge Judy

Jessica Perez as Hot Girl

Skylar Gaertner as Tucker