Tony Goldwyn as Joshua

F. Murray Abraham as Father Tardone

Kurt Fuller as Father Pat Hayes

Stacy Edwards as Maggie

Giancarlo Giannini as The Pope

Eddie Bo Smith Jr. as Theo

Michael Guido as Aaron

Matt Zeigler as Kevin

Colleen Camp as Joan Casey

Marc Grapey as Steve Casey (as Mark Grapey)

Rich Komenich as Ray Persini

Dale Calandra as Leo Persini

Cedric Young as Charlie

Tim Grimm as Bishop Anderson

Jordan Allen as Michael Reed

James Meeks as Muntoe

Bernie Landis as Rabbi Szeneth

John Sierros as Policeman (credit only)

David Pasquesi as Eli Cohen

Tom Brainard as Young Pastor

Tim Decker as Reverend Daily

Linsey Page Morton as Paulina

Beth Lacke as Sally

Tom Roland as Cardinal Riccardo

Coburn Goss as Father Delorenzo (as Coby Goss)

Jim Carrane as Father Tumelo

Ilio Bruno as Cardinal Napoli

Barrie D. Buckner Jr. as Henry (as Barrie D. Buckner)

Jason Borgardt as Randall

Ken Stimson as Reverend Williams

Bob O'Donnell as Bishop Representative

Tai Anderson as Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

Brad Avery as Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

David Carr as Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

Mark Lee as Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"

Mac Powell as Lost and Found Band - "Third Day"