Dylan Baker as Rulon Stacey

Tom Bower as Father Roger Schmit

Clancy Brown as Rob Debree

Steve Buscemi as Doc O'Connor

Jeremy Davies as Jedadiah Schultz

Clea DuVall as Amanda Gronich

Peter Fonda as Doctor Cantway

Janeane Garofalo as Catherine Connolly

Bill Irwin as Harry Woods

Joshua Jackson as Matt Galloway

Terry Kinney as Dennis Shepard

Laura Linney as Sherry Johnson

Amy Madigan as Reggie Fluty

Camryn Manheim as Rebecca Hilliker

Christina Ricci as Romaine Patterson

Lois Smith as Lucy Thompson

Frances Sternhagen as Marge Murray

Mark Webber as Aaron McKinney

Kathleen Chalfant as Anonymous Female Rancher

Nestor Carbonell as Moisés Kaufman

Andy Paris as Stephen Belber

Grant Varjas as Greg Pierotti

Kelli Simpkins as Leigh Fondakowski

Billie McBride as Waitress

Bill Christ as Man on the Porch

Regina Krueger as Alison Mears

Michael Emerson as Reverend

Margo Martindale as Trish Steger

Greg Pierotti as Jon Peacock

John McAdams as Jonas Slonaker

Michael K. Osborn as Murdock Cooper

Anne Cloud as Kristin Price

Ben Foster as Aaron Kreifels

Leslie Henson as Catherine Connolly's Partner

Garrett Neergaard as Russell Henderson

Daniel Ahearn as Arraignment Judge

Steef Sealy as Bill McKinney

Summer Phoenix as Jen Malmskog

Noah Fleiss as Shannon Shingleton

James Murtaugh as Reverend Fred Phelps

Richard Riehle as Henderson Trial Judge

Amanda Gronich as Zackie Salmon

Mercedes Herrero as Pam Sears

Stephen Belber as Anonymous Friend of Aaron McKinney

Barbara Pitts as Sherry Aanenson