Timothy Olyphant as Dennis

Zach Braff as Benji

Ben Weber as Patrick

Dean Cain as Cole

Billy Porter as Taylor

Matt McGrath as Howie

Justin Theroux as Marshall

Andrew Keegan as Kevin

Chris Payne Gilbert as Larry

John Mahoney as Jack

John Brandon as Mickey

Nia Long as Leslie

Mary McCormack as Anne

Diane McBain as Josephine

Jennifer Coolidge as Betty

Kerr Smith as Catcher

Nora Burns as Female Shopper

Michael Bergin as Kip Rogers

Christopher Wiehl as J. Crew Guy

David Youse as Barry

Brian Gaskill as Brian

Robert Arce as Purple Guy

Chris Weitz as Director

Christian Kane as Idaho Guy

Ken Kerman as Umpire

Kevin Cooney as Obstetrician

Paul Weitz as Assistant Director

Charlie Weber as Newbie

Matt Reid as Glen