Jeremy Northam as Harry Sawyer

Steve Zahn as Wayne Wayne Wayne Jr.

William H. Macy as Sheriff Chappy Dent

Ally Walker as Josephine "Joe" McClintock

Illeana Douglas as Doreen Schaefer

M.C. Gainey as Bob Maslow

Ron Perlman as Marshal Nalhober

Mo Gaffney as Mrs. Bromley

Paul Dooley as The Judge

Jillian Berard as Madison

Scarlett Pomers as Jency

Melissa Arnold as Other Happy Girl

Cassie Silva as Other Happy Girl

Tiffany Takara as Other Happy Girl

Tim Bagley as David

Michael Hitchcock as Steven

Ed Stone as Alton

Rance Howard as Ely

Derek Montgomery as Bully Boy

Kiva Lawrence as Pageant Judge

Carley Fink as "Little Light Girl"

David Shackelford as Varnel

Kim Story as Guard

Mark Illsley as Guard on Horse with Shotgun (uncredited)

Tim Cowgill as Local Cowboy (uncredited)

Krista Lewis as Bank Teller (uncredited)

Keo Woolford as Cabana Boy Kimo (uncredited)

Guy J. Graves as Tow Truck Driver (uncredited)