Dean Cain as Sheriff Scott Hanson

Jud Tylor as Sarah Walker

John Savage as Judge Willis

Gary Hudson as Robert Nielson

Eric Scott Woods as William

Bill Lewis as Kris Kringle

Jamie McRae as Susan Hanson

Cooper Barnes as Deputy Sam Bryant

Jodie Sweetin as Beth

Seth Menachem as Mark

Cole Sand as Alex

Blanca Blanco as Ana, Spanish News Reporter

Denise Poole as Betty