Philip Seymour Hoffman as Mickey Scarpato

Richard Jenkins as Richard Shelburn

Christina Hendricks as Jeannie Scarpato

John Turturro as Arthur 'Bird' Capezio

Eddie Marsan as Smilin' Jack Moran

Caleb Landry Jones as Leon Scarpato

Domenick Lombardozzi as Sal

Eddie McGee as Petey

Lenny Venito as Little Eddie

Peter Gerety as McKenna

Prudence Wright Holmes as Eleanor

Jonathan Gordon as Gary

Jack O'Connell as Mole Ferrell

Bill Buell as Ray

Rebecca Kling as Fat Pat

Bridget Barkan as Joyce

Michael Drayer as Danny

Molly Price as Joanie

Glenn Fleshler as Coleman Peets

Joseph Reiver as Driver

Arthur French as Lucien 'Old Lucy' Edwards

Dave Powers as Worker 1

Morgan Auld as Worker 2

Luis Bordoy as Man in Car

Joyce Van Patten as Aunt Sophie

Matthew Lawler as Officer Arbuckle

Danny Mastrogiorgio as Officer Eisenhower

Christopher McCann as Brookie Sutherland

Sophia Takal as Temple Graduate

Patrick Murney as Skully

Chris Cardona as Sunglasses

Michael Kaycheck as Ronnie

Carmine Famiglietti as Nick

J.R. Horne as Horse Race Announcer

Freddy Esposito as Bar Patron