Kevin Costner as Elliot Anderson

Jillian Estell as Eloise Anderson

Jennifer Ehle as Carol

Gillian Jacobs as Fay

Octavia Spencer as Rowena Jeffers

Bill Burr as Rick Reynolds

Joe Chrest as Dave

Indigo as Young Nurse

Mpho Koaho as Duvan

Angela Jones as Rita

Anthony Mackie as Jeremiah Jeffers

Paula Newsome as Judge Cummins

David Jensen as Eldridge

John McConnell as Vertell

Lindsey G. Smith as Andrea

André Holland as Reggie Davis

Ireyon Johnson as Kristen

Janeline Hayes as Dondi

Bertha Bindewald as Rosita

Ernest Wells as Uncle Victor

Joseph Fischer as Therapist

Robert Larriviere as Neighbor (Ted)

Lily Costner as Vocalist

Mark Kroner as Bailiff

Lola Phillips as School Girl (uncredited)

Janet Lynn Carey as Lawyer (uncredited)

Sadarias Harrell as Rowena's Family Member (uncredited)

Kenneth Kynt Bryan as Court Clerk (uncredited)

Ronnie Hooks as Elliott's Neighbor (uncredited)

Claire McReynolds as Eloise's Friend (uncredited)