Jeremy Sisto as Father John Buertein

Kristin Chenoweth as Linda Salerno

Brian Baumgartner as Fr. Ralph O'Brien

Bruce A. Young as Lloyd Montag

Amy Matthews as Nadine Brennan

Tony Papenfuss as Zeke

Greta Oglesby as Miriam

Ansa Akyea as James St. Clair

Isabell O'Connor as Tessie Thomas

Patrick Coyle as Steven Miller

Linda Kelsey as Corrine Buerlein

Lola Lesheim as Della

Gene Larche as Gus

Marion Markham as Diane

Ann Milligan as Judy

Emily Fradenburgh as Sharon

Marquetta Senters as Anita Mendoza

Tom Carey as Donald Dupree

Grant Richey as Caretaker

Peter Thoemke as George Andropolous

Dawn Brodey as Exotic Dancer

Jackson Bond as Danny Boyle

John Skelley as Henry

Elisabeth Oas as Maria

Ann Kellogg as Ellen

Laurie Flanigan as Ruth

Tena May Gallivan as Shirley

Landyn Banx as Diner Patron (uncredited)

Joel Thingvall as Bartender (uncredited)

Kirsten Gregerson as Church Lady