Paul McCloskey as Wayne Montgomery

Barbara Lessin as Andrea Montgomery

Mark Cray as John Craven

Michael Manfredo Jr. as Kyle Stratten

Mark Marcarian as Charles Craven

Jeremy Bishop as Luke Crossen

Nate Edwards as Henry Crossen

Bill Ushler as Detective Michael Hanlon

Lisa Panzer as Marti Dobson

Roberto Lombardi as Detective Joe Moretti

Jerry Ross as Ray Olsen

David M. Sitbon as Grey Mortimer

Shawn Shillingford as Christopher Hagans

Todd Kaylor as Detective Paul Brewer

Michael J. Panichelli Jr. as Detective John Haynes

Bruce DeSantis as Todd Montgomery

Emily Spiegel as Monica Montgomery

Cara Duncan as Crime Scene Investigator

James Schaeffer as Detective David Shaw

Jenn Phillips as Reporter

Fearon Derry as Newscaster (voice)

Benjamin P. Ablao Jr. as Detective Chris Dolendo

Tony J. Spadaccini as Detective Bill Price

Devin Kates as Seth Hayden

Joey Garrison as Jared

Brinke Stevens as Julie Quinn

Ruth Weisberg as Narrator (voice)

Daniel Eyre as Todd Montgomery - Age 2

Emily Eyre as Monica Montgomery- Baby

Florence Coia as Rebecca Collins

Damien Colletti as Charles Craven Jr.

Michael Agnew as Joseph Barker

Brandon Macker as Daniel Azzurri

John Coia as Alan Montgomery

Sabrina Manfredo as Allison Stratten

Taylor Sampere as Austin

Kati Jordan as Holly Craven

Kyle Field as Pete (Reaction Video #1)

Kelly Tull as Melissa (Reaction Video #2)

Nikki Krumm as Sarah (Reaction Video #2)

Robbie Sanders as Brian (Reaction Video #3)

Jack A. Walker as Chip (Reaction Video #4)

Al Holmes as Gary (Reaction Video #5)

June Munson as Marti’s Assistant

Michael Manfredo as Detective Tony Capello

Jennifer Griffith-Munson as Marie Craven

Kevin Ashley as Chester Donnell

Edward Kime as Bookstore Customer

Lucas Brown as Bookstore Customer

Dave Wrighteous as Bookstore Customer

Elizabeth Clark as Bookstore Customer

Allan Kleban as Bookstore Customer

Andrew Schwartz as Bookstore Customer

Michael Oreszczyn as Bookstore Customer

Rin Cyano as Victim

Amber Manfredo as Victim

William Ruh as Victim

Matt Veltri as Victim

Kelly Alexander as Victim

Bailey Heintzelman as Victim

Mikaela Knapp as Victim

Jay Cusack as Victim

Bill Jackson as Victim

Dave Wascavage as Victim

Stacey Lowery as Victim

Melissa Torrence as Victim

Beth Sikma as Victim

Erick Kneisler as Victim

Fran Slaczka as Victim

Sue Morrow as Victim

Karen Kennedy as Victim

Mary Brown as Victim

Glynis Sampere as Debbie

Lauren Gaskell as D.B.I. Investigator

Derek Rushlow as Mike

Brendan Bertolini as Fortunato

Eric Moyer as Lewis