Joaquin Phoenix as Abe

Emma Stone as Jill

Jamie Blackley as Roy

Parker Posey as Rita

Joe Stapleton as Professor

Jack Haven as Braylin Student

Ethan Phillips as Jill's Father

Betsy Aidem as Jill's Mother

Paula Plum as College President

Allison Gallerani as Braylin Student

Katelyn Semer as Braylin Student

Leah Anderson as Student Giving Directions

Nancy Carroll as Professor

Nancy Giles as President's Assistant

Henry Stram as Cocktail Party Guest

Geoff Schuppert as Cocktail Party Guest

Robert Petkoff as Paul

Alex Dunn as Student in Classroom

Ron Chez as Professor in Cafeteria

Tamara Hickey as Professor in Cafeteria

Sophie von Haselberg as April

Ben Rosenfield as April's Friend

Michael Goldsmith as April's Friend

Lindsay McWhorter as April's Friend

Meredith Hagner as April's Friend

Jamie Rosenstein as April's Friend

Susan Pourfar as Carol

Gary Wilmes as Carol's Friend

David Aaron Baker as Carol's Friend

Nancy Villone as Carol's Friend

Christine Mascott as Waitress

Tom Kemp as Judge Spangler

Britt Faulkner as Student in Classroom

Marina Re as Amusement Park Attendant

David Pittu as Faculty Meeting Professor

Mark Zeisler as Radio Announcer (voice)

Adrienne Taylor as Cellist

Tina Benko as TV Announcer

Kate McGonigle as Ellie

John Franchi as Pedestrian

Jonah Coppolelli as Boy at Amusement Park (uncredited)