Tom Everett Scott as Joe Matthews / Micah Matthias

Sarah Lancaster as Rachel Troyler

Thomas Kapanowski as Bobby Matthews / Bobby Matthias

Kelly McGillis as Bertha Troyler

Nicole Badaan as Kim

Annie Kitral as Lydia Troyler

Katherine DeBoer as Chloe Styles

Marianna Alacchi as Anna Troyler

Ken Strunk as Eli Troyler

Greg Violand as Ed Spencer

John Eby as Sam Phillips

Geoffrey Hoffman as Dylan Matthias

Kaitlyn Sapp as Elise

Chris Van Vliet as Reporter #1

Jeannie Madison as Reporter #2

Madison Blake as Ypung Rachel Troyler

Dave McConnell as Frank Troyer

Joe Kurak as Head Official

Dave Durch as Disheveled Guy

Kyle Primous as Mechanic

Serena Miller as Cashier

Kris Leiter as Umpire

Mary Anne Prevost as Mary Anne (Bank Teller)

Trenton Huff as Bobby Double

Abe M. Yoder as Horse & Buggy Wrangler

Nicole Miller as Horse Trainer

Blaze as Buggy Horse

Curtis Blackburn as Amish Youths Chasing Buggy

Jason Burroughs as Amish Youths Chasing Buggy

Ryan Schultz as Grungy Guy

Kirk Putman as Garaway Baseball Team

Michah VanFossen as Garaway Baseball Team

Brandon Weaver as Garaway Baseball Team

B.J. Schwartz as Garaway Baseball Team

Benjamin Mason as Garaway Baseball Team

Brandon Johnson as Garaway Baseball Team

Zach Huffman as Garaway Baseball Team

Tyrrell Keim as Garaway Baseball Team

Jerrod F. Hunt as Garaway Baseball Team

Joe Haynes as Garaway Baseball Team

Seth Miller as Garaway Baseball Team

Parker Barnhouse as Garaway Baseball Team