Allison Williams as Peter Pan

Christopher Walken as Captain Hook

Christian Borle as George Darling / Smee

Kelli O'Hara as Mrs. Darling

Taylor Louderman as Wendy Darling

Minnie Driver as Adult Wendy Darling / Narrator

Jake Lucas as John Darling

John Allyn as Michael Darling

Alanna Saunders as Tiger Lily

Caitlin Houlahan as Jane Darling

Jason Gotay as Tootles

Alan H. Green as Cookson

Jacob Guzman as Twin 1

David Guzman as Twin 2

F. Michael Haynie as Slightly

Austin Lesch as Bill Jukes

Chris McCarrell as Nibs

Michael Park as Cecco

Bryce Ryness as Starkey

Ryan Steele as Curly

Chris Sullivan as Noodler

Ryan Andes as Admiral Crichton

Dyllón Burnside as Prickles

John Arthur Greene as Robert Mullins / Islander

Michael Hartung as Sniffler

Garett Hawe as Patches

Dominique Kelley as Ensemble

Marty Lawson as Ensemble

Gary Milner as The Vicar / Islander

Michael Munday as Ensemble

Andrew Pirozzi as Ensemble

Daniel Quadrino as Bunting

T. Oliver Reid as Oliver Shreeks / Islander

C. J. Tyson as Ensemble

Matt Wall as Skylights / Islander

Keenan D. Washington as Ensemble

Charlie Williams as Ensemble

Alex Wong as Ensemble

Helen Anker as Dancer / Chorus

Stephanie Kim as Dancer / Chorus

Sarah O'Gleby as Dancer / Chorus

Kathryn Terza as Mermaid / understudy Tiger Lily

James Brown III as Islander / Pirate

Henry Gottfried as understudy Peter Pan/swing for lost boys