Cheyenne Jackson as Eli Faisel

Anthony Rapp as Logan Joyce

Jessica Richards as Rose

Mitchell Jarvis as Shakespeare / Janitor

Kelsey Carthew as Simonia

Chasen Bauer as Windsor Bisby

Nicole Tompkins as Arden

Philip Labes as Jay

Christopher Matias Aguila as Terry

Marquis Wood as Marcus Robertson

Camille Cregan as Penny

Stacie Mitchell as Keyla

Pamela Bowen as Ms. Wilt

Harrison White as Board President

Chuck Lines as Tech Director

Thessa Mloe as Techie #2

Dia Tequali as Fairy #1

Dahlia Tequali as Fairy #2

Baker Chase Powell as Theseus

Maisie Klompus as Hippolyta

Oscar Rodriguez as Philostrate

Nick Zayas as Quince

Ally Cron-DeVico as Flute

Joey Luthman as Lysander

Timmy Lee as Demetrius

Kristen Corona as Helena

Jennifer Newton as Mother

Robert Paul Taylor as Gym Teacher

Ricco Ross as Mr. Robertson