Melissa Joan Hart as Rose DeMarco

Jaleel White as Paul Greenberg

Barry Watson as Nick DeMarco

Melissa Sagemiller as Carol Guthrie

John Ratzenberger as Warden

Scott Grimes as John Guthrie

Wendy Williams as Pastor Ruth

Tucker Meek as Billy Guthrie

Alimi Ballard as Steve Repperton

John Ratzenberger as Warden Jeffrey Mitchell

Matthew Porter as Walter Banfield

P.J. Marino as Foreman

Dior Raye as Olivia

Andrea Cirie as Mrs. Stanwyck

Lucy DeVito as June

Michael Patrick Lane as Bartender

Brian J. Carter as Ernie

Matthew F. O'Connor as Phil

Bonnie Discepolo as Woman in Bar

Cameron Meyer as Chairwoman

Jonathan Savage as Jerky Kid

Kairo Chelani Ballard as Little Boy 1

Braydon Wilkerson as Little Boy 2

Christopher Savage as Little Boy 3

Charlie Santoyo as Little Boy 4

Mason Lahd Wilkerson as Little Boy 5

Olivia Bell-Cross as Little Girl 1

Destiny Figueroa as Little Girl 2

Naya Seray Ballard as Little Girl 3

Mitch Longley as Mr. Waxman

Enrique Menéndez as Parole Board Member

Brian Hart as Police Officer

Becky Baker as Young Mother

Joseph Basile as Contractor (uncredited)

Erik Bloomquist as Policeman (uncredited)

Elizabeth Hart as Elf (uncredited)

Mackenzie Lee Hart as Elf (uncredited)

William Hart as Poker Player (uncredited)

Jamie Leo as Extra (uncredited)

Hudson Meek as Wiseman (uncredited)

Mark Wilkerson as Sentry (uncredited)

Tucker Wilkerson as Little Boy on Santa's Lap (uncredited)