Hedy Lamarr as Jenny Hager

George Sanders as John Evered

Louis Hayward as Ephraim Poster

Gene Lockhart as Isaiah Poster

Hillary Brooke as Meg Saladine

Rhys Williams as Deacon Adams

June Storey as Lena Tempest

Moroni Olsen as Rev. Thatcher

Olive Blakeney as Mrs. Hollis

Kathleen Lockhart as Mrs. Partridge

Alan Napier as Judge Henry Saladine

Dennis Hoey as Tim Hager

Ed Agresti as Congregation Member (uncredited)

John Alban as Congregation Member (uncredited))

Fred Aldrich as Sailor in Saloon (uncredited)

Jessie Arnold as Mrs. Thatcher (uncredited)

Frank Baker as Congregation Member (uncredited)

Edward Biby as Mr. Patridge (uncredited)

Clancy Cooper as Lumberjack (uncredited)

Ralph Dunn as Lumberjack (uncredited)

Harry Evans as Congregation Member (uncredited)

Edith Evanson as Mrs. Coggins (uncredited)

Al Ferguson as Lumberjack (uncredited)

Fred Graham as Street Rowdy (uncredited)

Billy Gray as Boy on Bridge (uncredited)

Teddy Infuhr as Boy on Bridge (uncredited)

Ian Keith as Lincoln Pittridge (uncredited)

Johnny Kern as Sailor in Saloon (uncredited)

Connie Lamont as Congregation Member (uncredited)

Ian MacDonald as Boat Captain (uncredited)

George Magrill as Poster's Workman (uncredited)

Jo Ann Marlowe as Jenny as a Girl (uncredited)

Francis Pierlot as Dr. Bailey (uncredited)

Christopher Severn as Ephraim Poster - as a Child (uncredited)

Brick Sullivan as Poster's Workman (uncredited)

Ray Teal as Alex Duncan (uncredited)

Harry Wilson as Lumberjack (uncredited)

Katherine Yorke as Mrs. Pittridge (uncredited)

Chief Yowlachie as Guide (uncredited)