Aaron Tveit as John "Maz" Mazello

Tyler Hoechlin as Johnathan "Dells" Dellamonica

Jay Hayden as Vincent "Vinnie" Maltzan

Duke Davis Roberts as Ty Dellamonica

Joseph Mazzello as Pat Murray

Chace Crawford as Arthur Barone

Ryan Pinkston as Jonathan Garvey

Matt Bush as David Stein

Manny Montana as Zapata

Toby Hemingway as Palacco

David Del Rio as Tree

Jim Belushi as Jim

Philip Winchester as Fotch

Michael Fishman as Antonelli

Matt Barr as Anthony

Billy Gardell as Umpire Haze

Michael Consiglio as Dave Schwartz

Justin Matthew Gallegos as

Rick Iwasaki as

Zachary Scott Green as

Anna B. Shaffer as Spectator (uncredited)

Austin Kane as Young Maz