Toby Stephens as Jay Gatsby

Mira Sorvino as Daisy Buchanan

Paul Rudd as Nick Carraway

Martin Donovan as Tom Buchanan

Francie Swift as Jordan Baker

Heather Goldenhersh as Myrtle Wilson

Matt Malloy as Klipspringer

Bill Camp as Wilson

Richard Jutras as Owl Eyes

Jerry Grayson as Wolfsheim

Janine Theriault as Catherine

Alex Bisping as Buchanan's Butler

Claudia Besso as Lucille

Gillian Ferrabee as Lil

Tim Rozon as Dandy Man

Tony Calabretta as Gatsby's Domestic Thuggish Butler

Andrea Sadler as Miss Baedecker

Jason Conyers as Witness at Accident

Allen Altman as Policeman at Accident

Ernie Jackson as Gatsby's Gardener

Paul Hopkins as Policeman Detective

Martin Kevan as Gatsby's Butler

Megan Broadman as Pammy Buchanan

Dean Patrick Fleming as Policeman

Burt Harris as Henry C. Gotz