Will Ferrell as Robert Benson

Kristen Wiig as Sarah Benson

Jessica Lowndes as Bridget / Jodi

Alyvia Alyn Lind as Sully

Jake Weary as Dwayne Tisdale

Erik Palladino as Sheriff

Bryan Safi as Charlie

Debra Christofferson as Ellen

Carolyn Hennesy as Debby

Antonia Stout as Julia

Mara Hall as Coffee Lady

Matt Corboy as Stan

Robert Gantzos as Jerry

Cal Gibson as Old Man

Brooke Lyons as Christine

Kellita Smith as Officer Mason