J.K. Simmons as Mr. Gallo

Lio Tipton as Ginnie

Emile Hirsch as Martin

Meta Golding as Kelly

Jon Daly as Jimothy

Kristen Schaal as Roberta

Taran Killam as Gary

Hunter Parrish as Kip

Shannon Woodward as Lois

Tom Waite as Squat Cop

BoJesse Christopher as Grizzled Bartender

Stephanie Allynne as Tracy

Rebecca Drysdale as Lizzie

Connor Barrett as Dean the Waiter

Blake Perlman as Bartender

Xosha Roquemore as Megan

Jon Bass as Trevor

Trenton Rostedt as Bri-Baby

Milana Vayntrub as Terri Sadler

Mindy Chon as Mindy

Eddie Alfano as Jail Police Officer

Sarah Adina as River Room Bartender

Eddie Perez as Policeman

Corey Reynolds as Greg