Paula Abdul as Paula Abdul

Joe Gatto as Joe Gatto

James Murray as James Murray

Brian Quinn as Brian Quinn

Sal Vulcano as Sal Vulcano

Jaden Smith as Jaden Smith

Joey Fatone as Joey Fatone

Salvatore Volcano Sr. as Pop Volcano

Evan Castelloe as Frat Bro #1

Sierra Pond as Staten Island '94 Girl

Madison Bailey as Bowling Alley Girl

Jessica Megan Rivera as Unimpressed Backstage '94 Girl

Sailor Larocque as Miami Restaurant Girl #1

Andrea Andrade as Miami Restaurant Girl #2

Camille Robinson as Miami Restaurant Girl #3

Will Ferrell as Miami Restaurant Guy #4

Josefina Boneo as Miami Panicked Girl

Guilherme Apollonio as Miami Hotel Valet

Jordan Sherley as '94 Concert Panicked Girl

Mark Jigarjian as 1994 Ticket Attendant

Drew McDermott as Busker Guitar Player

Tiago Ferreira as Soldier Stranded in Boat

Chase Dominick as 1st Mate

Casey Mills as Cashier - Rest Shop

Katherine Esparza as High School Girl '94

Gregory Neil Howard Jr. as Tour Guide

Casey Jost as Sam

Jenna Elkadi as Miami Party Girl

Kane Hodder as Bodyguard

Jeff Glover as Bouncer (uncredited)

Hunter Deno as Dream Waitress (uncredited)

Barbara Hawkins-Scott as Waitress (uncredited)

Todd Shevchik as Larry (uncredited)