Louisa Krause as Jane

Gabriel Ebert as Jack

Eliza Dushku as Bianca

Polly Draper as Mom

Amir Arison as Rob

Jon Bass as Steve

Lindsay Arber as Peaseblossom

Franco Gonzalez as Jose

Gregg Edelman as Father

Sal Ardisi as Audience Member (as Salvatore Ardisi)

Margaret Donlin as Laughing Woman

Gary Hilborn as Gyp

Greg Keller as Paul

Benj Mirman as Friend 1

Kristina Mueller as Mustardseed

Anisha Nagarajan as Cynthia

Nathaniel Peart as Lysander

Nicole Pursell as Bookstore Worker

Lance Roberts as Waiter

Bianca Rutigliano as Friend 2

Paulina Simkin as Shakespeare Lover

Nick Stevenson as Director

Margaux Susi as Friend 3

Sarah Wharton as Kim

Stephen Dexter as Demetrius/Holyman/Various(voice) (uncredited)

Jesse Luciani as Theater patron(uncredited)

Yamileth Palacios as Restaurant Patron(uncredited)