Andrew Baglini as Will

Mark Schroeder as Jacob

Noelle Meixell as Julie Foster

Andrew Sammaciccia as Wheeler

Jody Seymour as Lydia

Bart Mallard as Al

Matthew Petrilla as Older Will

Katie Fitzpatrick as Jennifer Cooley

Jake Voigtsberger as Young Will

Colin Hartzell as Young Danny

Jeff Vent as Young Jacob

Ryan Foster as Hallway Passerby

David Rhoton as Young Wheeler

Gina Aversa as Young Julie

Ron Beck as Coach Knight

Brian Konowal as Franklin

Brendan Clay as Metalhead

Shannon Farrelly as Kelly

Stephen Konowal as Knight's QB

Megan Rucidlo as Julie's Friend

Claire McFarland as Prom Voter

Brian J.M.A. Christian as English Teacher

Christopher Franzini as 8th Grade Dance Chaperone

Lou De Vlieger as Dean

Scott Bosch as Homeroom Teacher

David Teter as Charles

Jason Altman as Capsule Speaker

Adam Colbertson as Cafeteria Bully

Patty Kropp as Gym Girl

Patrick Mazza as Party Listener

Andy Pratt as Dance Chaperone #2

Kevin Kelly as Billy Winston

Abigail Petrilla as Yearbook Photographer

Bil Willetts as Slacker #1

Jake Kaminsky as Slacker #2