James Stewart as Tom Jeffords

Jeff Chandler as Cochise

Debra Paget as Sonseeahray

Basil Ruysdael as Gen. Oliver Howard

Will Geer as Ben Slade

Joyce Mackenzie as Terry

Arthur Hunnicutt as Milt Duffield

Robert Adler as Lonergan - Stage Driver (uncredited)

Trevor Bardette as Stage Passenger (uncredited)

Chris Willow Bird as Nochalo (uncredited)

Raymond Bramley as Col. Bernall (uncredited)

Chet Brandenburg as Miner (uncredited)

Argentina Brunetti as Nalikadeya - Cochise's Wife (uncredited)

Harry Carter as Miner (uncredited)

Iron Eyes Cody as Teese (uncredited)

J.W. Cody as Pionsenay - Chosen Warrior (uncredited)

Heinie Conklin as Townsman (uncredited)

Dolores Christine Cypert as American Indian/Redbird (uncredited)

Aubrey Lee Dale as Indian (uncredited)

John Doucette as Mule Driver (uncredited)

Robert Dover as Machogee (uncredited)

Nacho Galindo as Barber (uncredited)

Robert Griffin as John Lowrie (uncredited)

Jack Kenny as Townsman (uncredited)

Bob Kortman as Minor Role (uncredited)

Mickey Kuhn as Bob Slade (uncredited)

Al Kunde as Townsman (uncredited)

Jack Lee as Boucher (uncredited)

Ted Mapes as Mail Rider (uncredited)

John Marston as Maury (uncredited)

Frank McGrath as Barfly (uncredited)

Charles Morton as Townsman (uncredited)

Edwin Rand as Sergeant (uncredited)

John Rice as Townsman (uncredited)

Allen D. Sewall as Barfly (uncredited)

Jay Silverheels as Geronimo (uncredited)

Charles Soldani as Skinyea - Chosen Warrior (uncredited)

Dorothy Teters as Indian (uncredited)

Richard Van Opel as Bernall's Adjutant (uncredited)

John War Eagle as Nahilzay (uncredited)

Billy Wilkerson as Juan (uncredited)

Bud Wolfe as Man Saying "...or a Blasted Liar" (uncredited)