Hugh Dancy as Nick

Liane Balaban as Gabrielle

Mamie Gummer as Stella

Benjamin Walker as Andy

Michael Chernus as Michael

Jonathan Gutierrez as Hector

Ryann Shane as Juliette

Jesse Stevenson as Ian

Jasai Chase-Owens as Frankie

Kathryn Faughnan as Jen

Gillian Jacobs as Zoe

Bill Camp as Coach Buehl

Bess Wohl as Gretchen

David Zayas as Ramon

Laura Heisler as Sandy

Patch Darragh as Brian

Daniel Farcher as Brute

James Biberi as Ref

Gary Cherkassky as Soccer Player #1

Christopher Clawson as Bartender

Donato DeMarinis as Opera Patron

Anna Kuchma as Hooker