Alison Sweeney as Hannah Swensen

Cameron Mathison as Detective Mike Kingston

Barbara Niven as Delores Swensen

Gabriel Hogan as Norman Rhodes

Toby Levins as Bill Todd

Lisa Durupt as Andrea Todd

Aaron Pearl as Gary Koeler

Hugo Steele as Reggie

Nick Marinos as John Morse

Juliana Wimbles as Lisa Herman

Lauren K. Robek as Janet

Garry Chalk as Mayor Bascomb

Jesse Moss as Kevin Miller

Rebecca Toolan as Mrs. Houser

Marion Eisman as Mrs. Norton

Ty Olsson as Sheriff Jim Grant

Venus Terzo as Nettie Grant

Hannah Pederson as Paige Miller

Lina Renna as Lucy Miller

Jillian Fargey as Sophie Bascomb

Brenna O'Brien as Carly Winters

Flora Karas as Clerk

Viv Leacock as Deputy Peters

Marilyn Norry as Edna Morse

Matt Fentiman as Car Owner