Sarah Silverman as Gretchen

Michael Sheen as Henry

Christine Adams as Beth

Maria Blasucci as Deedee

Daniel Edward Mora as Kurtis

Yannis Bariamis as Seth

Alex Warren as Vet Secretary

Harvey J. Alperin as Man (Bible Study Member)

William Stanford Davis as Man 2 (Bible Study Member)

Jonny Fritz as Bible Study Member

Alice Itzigsohn as Tax Office Receptionist

Samuel Kroll as Tax Office Employee

Lawrence Mandley as Bible Study Member

Murphy Patrick Martin as Bible Study Member

Kate Shelton as Tax Office Client 2

Thom Shelton as Tax Office Client 1

Zach Steel as Bible Study Member