Catherine Keener as Kate

Amanda Peet as Mary

Oliver Platt as Alex

Rebecca Hall as Rebecca

Ann Morgan Guilbert as Andra

Lois Smith as Mrs. Portman

Sarah Steele as Abby

Thomas Ian Nicholas as Eugene

Elizabeth Keener as Cathy

Elise Ivy as Marissa

Josh Pais as Adam

Griffin Frazen as Shopper

Reggie Austin as Shopper

Scott Cohen as Dr. Lerner

Paul Sparks as Blind Date

Amy Wright as Erin

Arthur French as Man Waiting for a Table

Neal Lerner as Leaf Man

Mandy Olsen Cogman as Salesgirl

Maddie Corman as Shopper

Alice Spivak as Shopper

John Srednicki as Tommy

Timothy Doyle as Kevin

Emma Myles as Salesgirl

Rebecca Budig as Big Back

Romy Rosemont as Carrie-Ann

Kathleen Doyle as Anita

Sarah Vowell as Shopper

Jason Mantzoukas as Shopper

Kevin Corrigan as Don

Elizabeth Berridge as Elyse

Erica Fae as Shopper

Michael Panes as Shopper

Charles Techman as Homeless Man

Portia as Mrs. Melnick