Johnny Simmons as Dr. Peter Newmans

Brittany Snow as Michelle

J.K. Simmons as James Newmans

Jane Lynch as Caroline

Maria Bello as Brenda Newmans

Beck Bennett as Luke

Kumail Nanjiani as Rich

Paul Wesley as Charlie

Charlotte McKinney as Attractive Woman

Ken Marino as Mr. Hanson

Matt Jones as Max

Illeana Douglas as Linda

Laraine Newman as Noema Willcoxen

Brian Doyle-Murray as Stagehand

Joey Greer as Doug

Lenora Crichlow as Nikki

Vanessa Ragland as Jenny

Bobby Flay as Himself

Sam Robards as Dr. Lawson

Blake Cooper as Josh

Roxanna Dunlop as Montana

Lauren Shaw as Rosalyn

Nathan Cooper as Host

Tara Grant as Tinder Girl #3