Alexander Molony as Peter Pan

Ever Anderson as Wendy Darling

Jude Law as James Hook

Yara Shahidi as Tinker Bell

Alyssa Wapanatâhk as Tiger Lily

Jim Gaffigan as Sam "Smee" Smiegel

Joshua Blue Pickering as John Darling

Jacobi Jupe as Michael Darling

Alan Tudyk as George Darling

Molly Parker as Mary Darling

Florence Bensberg as Curly

Sebastian Billingsley-Rodriguez as Nibs

Noah Matthews Matofsky as Slightly

Caelan Edie as Tootles

Kelsey Yates as Twin

Skyler Yates as Twin

Diana Tsoy as Birdie

Felix de Sousa as Bellweather

John DeSantis as Bill Jukes

Garfield Wilson as Gurley

Ian Tracey as Sallyport

Mark Acheson as Old Clemson

Jesse James Pierce as Skylight

Gemita Samarra as Mermaid

Cassie Van Wolde as Wendy Darling (Adult)

Deborah Ramsay as Wendy Darling (Old)

Paloma Nuñez as Starkey

Paul Cheng as Scrimshaw Sam

Mike Ching as Dirtbag Benny

Nora Mcadam as Tiger Lily's Grandmother

Kevin Cameron as Black Matthew

Marguerite Kalhor as Puppeteer

Mackenzie Nibbe as Children's Choir Ensemble

Steve Hunt as Pirate Chorus Member

Roy Dilbert as Pirate Chorus Member

Nick Preston as Pirate Chorus Member

Arthur Lee Rose as Pirate Chorus Member

Jason Demidoff as Pirate Chorus Member

Tony Chris Kazoleas as Pirate Chorus Member

Boyd Ferguson as Gundeck Pirate

Atlin Mitchell as Jolly Roger Pirate

Chad Bellamy as Jolly Roger Pirate

Darryl Quon as Jolly Roger Pirate

Fraser Aitcheson as Jolly Roger Pirate

Jason Day as Jolly Roger Pirate

Joshua Mazerolle as Jolly Roger Pirate

Todd Allen Johnson as Jolly Roger Pirate

Nathaniel Shuker as Jolly Roger Pirate

Curtis Braconnier as Skull Rock Pirate

Trevor Addie as Skull Rock Pirate

Will Erichson as Skull Rock Pirate

Brad Kelly as Skull Rock Pirate

Eclilson de Jesus as Skull Rock Pirate

Marshall Bingham as Skull Rock Pirate

Angela Uyeda as Skull Rock Pirate

Jack Kingsley as Jolly Roger Pirate / Skull Rock Pirate

Mark Krysko as Jolly Roger Pirate / Skull Rock Pirate

Ryan Handley as Jolly Roger Pirate / Skull Rock Pirate

Lars Grant as Jolly Roger Pirate / Skull Rock Pirate

Danny Hospes as Jolly Roger Pirate / Gangly Pirate

Marcel Robert as Pirate

Douglas Podzun as Pirate

Stuart Murray as Pirate

Rod Megill as Pirate

Chanelle Hunter as Peter's Shadow

Matt Reimer as Hook's Shadow