Chiwetel Ejiofor as Carlton Pearson

Martin Sheen as Oral Roberts

Danny Glover as Gilbert Pearson

Dola Rashad as Gina Pearson

Jason Segel as Henry

LaKeith Stanfield as Reggie

Joni Bovill as Yvette Flunder

Tracey Bonner as Kiesha

Selena Anduze as Claire

Tonea Stewart as Lillie Ruth Pearson

Andrew Masset as John Heines

Ric Reitz as Richard Roberts

Roxzane T. Mims as Minnie

Greg Lutz as Pat Robertson

Michael Cotter as John Felton

Dustin Lewis as Ron

Stacey Sargeant as Nicky Brown

Clark Harris as Ben Sands

Nic Starr as Terry Allen

Trayce Malachi as Julian Peterson

Jason E. Brooks as Kevin

Beverly Bowens as Jenelle

Cecil M. Henry as Bishop

A.J. Johnson as Lady Bishop

Brian Kayode-Patrick Johnson as Young Bishop

Allie McCulloch as Lawyer

Gerard Catus as Announcer

Juan Gaspard as Church Member (uncredited)