Jewel Staite as Katharine

Connor Fox as Derek

Susie Abromeit as Mindy

Michael Aills as Jared

Matty Ferraro as Casey

Jerry Leggio as Frank

T.W. Leshner as Richard

Jess Sylvia as Sally

Alex Hardee as Jamie

Arvilla Riddick as Elderly Woman

Wallace Merck as Mayor Dinkins

Douglas M. Griffin as Policeman

Kennon Kepper as Young Boy

Lucy Faust as Young Boy's Mother

Sam Schulak as Scrawny Teenager

T.J. Toups as Townsperson

Lawrence Turner as Vinny

Sam Medina as Native American

Shadoe Knight as Torturer 1

Levy Easterly as Torturer 2

Danny Broume as Torturer 3

Ae Voight as Coffin Maker

Budd Bird as Town Drunk 1939

Michael Brossard as Cop 1939

Shane Dufrene as Cop 1939

Lee Kelly as Frank 1950

Tyler Galpin as Young Boy 1950

Jeff Galpin as Driver 1950

Chris J. Fanguy as Passenger 1950

William Maursky as Passenger 1950