Jason Ritter as Bill Hart

Jaime King as Beth Hart

Marianna Palka as Jill Hart

Brighton Sharbino as Tiffany Hart

Rio Mangini as Max Hart

Kingston Foster as Cindy Hart

Martin Starr as Todd

Jason Maybaum as Jed

Sol Rodríguez as Annabelle

Liisa Lee as Dog voice

Caroline Aaron as Nana

Roger Guenveur Smith as Steven Sheriff

Bill Smitrovich as Papa

Ren Hanami as Family Lawyer

Asia Mattu as Dog voice

Jaime Moyer as Plumber Joe

Eric Edelstein as (uncredited)