Robert Young as John Davis

Laraine Day as Nora Davis

Fay Bainter as Trudy Strauss

Nigel Bruce as Herbert V. Allison

Margaret O'Brien as Margaret

William Severn as Peter

Elisabeth Risdon as Mrs. Bailey

Doris Lloyd as Mrs. Barrie

Halliwell Hobbes as Mr. Barrie

Heather Thatcher as Mrs. Harris

Jill Esmond as Susan Fleming

G.P. Huntley as 'Rugged' (as G.P. Huntley Jr.)

Lisa Golm as Frau Weber

Eric Snowden as Porter (uncredited)

Leyland Hodgson as The Censor (uncredited)

John Burton as Surgeon (uncredited)