Kimberly Williams-Paisley as Ida Graber

Tammy Blanchard as Amy Roberts

Fay Masterson as Jill Green

Madison Mason as Levi Brennaman

Gary Graham as Henry Taskey

Darcy Rose Byrnes as Rebecca Knepp

Karley Scott Collins as Katie Graber

Eugene Byrd as Danny

Bruce Nozick as Leonard

Amy Sloan as Rachel Knepp

John Churchill as Charlie Roberts

Madison Davenport as Mary Beth Graber

Matt Letscher as Gideon Graber

Eric Nenninger as State Trooper

Willow Geer as Judith

Christopher Curry as Minister

Kate Fuglei as Shelly

Jim Metzler as Sheriff

Bob Rumnock as Reporter

Emilee Wallace as Teacher Ruth

Jessica Dickey as Melinda

Chloe Madison as Sarah Knepp

Taylor Ann Thompson as Hannah

Trevor Thompson as Jacob

David Mazouz as Andy Roberts

Dale Wade Davis as Rachel's Husband

Joel Schmidt as Melinda's Husband

David Curtis as Amish Elder

Sammy Jack as Knepp Boy #1

Gabriel Welch as Knepp Boy #2

Elijah Tadros as Ryan Roberts

Caleb Babcock as Schoolboy (uncredited)

Daphne Blunt as Lilly (uncredited)

Isabella Interian as Lydia (uncredited)

Marcus Shultz as Knepp Teenager (uncredited)

Johnny Wilson as Sheriff's Deputy (uncredited)