Heather Matarazzo as Darby

Kirsten Vangsness as Sunny

Felicia Day as Robin

Christina Moore as Mrs. Montgomery

Joel McHale as Judge Lepetri

Heather Turman as Chloe

Paul Scheer as Cuthbert

Kate Flannery as Ms. Jenkins

Jillian Armenante as Officer Wheeler

Mindy Sterling as Glenda Sue

Alexis G. Zall as Taylor

Brian Jordan Alvarez as Raymond

Chris Redd as Officer Buskill

Amir Talai as Mo

Vivian Bang as Mi-Yung

Hazel Armenante as Alex

Pamela Dunlap as Grandma Jenkins

Paul Witten as Julius

Joe Fria as Giles

Chris Coppola as Jimmy Palicelli

Sheila Thiele as Megan